Friday, 25 February 2022

German Hyperinflation Causes, Versailles vs Monetary Policy


Article 231 of the 1919 Treaty of Versailles placed sole responsibility for WW1 onto Germany. Consequently, Germany had to pay reparations to the Allies, totalling 132bn Gold Marks (31.4bn USD). This debt represented 120-130% of national output, placing an economic burden on the relatively foreign debt free Germany. Keynes referred to the Reparations Commission as “an instrument of oppression and rapine” (due to its deviation from Wilson’s Fourteen Points.) Adding to Germany’s domestic debts, war pension liabilities and ordinary expenses, this evidently appeared unrealistic, particularly given the political volatility of the time.


                                       Signing of the Treaty of Versailles

P. Michael et al, pinpoint the start of hyperinflation as July 1922, shortly after the murder of  foreign minister Rathenau, who believed high inflation “took from those who had and gave to those who had not”. This was also a time when Germany halted reparations payments and escalated their printing of notes, both to profit from seigniorage and increase the money supply, as Germany’s negative balance of payments drove up prices and wages, weakening the mark against foreign currencies. Allan Young contended that inflation was the result, not the cause of the mark’s depreciation, as price levels rose in excess of the increase in money supply.


                                               Graph showing the Mark's steep decline in Value

The French occupation of the Ruhr in late December 1922 further deepened the crisis, as national output fell by 50%, while resisting workers had to be paid by the government. The mark sharply rose to 500,000 per dollar vs 272 in June. Further evidencing that Germany’s politicians had little freedom in economic policy, they once again had to choose inflation over revolution, for the democratic government to survive threats from the far left and right.


                               French troops occupy the Ruhr, a key industrial area

 


No comments:

Post a Comment

Stresemann and the Solution

  Stresemann’s 102-day stint as Chancellor from August to November 1923 is regarded as the turning point in the crisis. He has been given cr...